9 Things I Wonder About Other Writers

While I was reading blogs–yes, I still do that–I came across this post by my friend Alison, which was inspired by Kristen. I really liked it.

I have been thinking a lot about that label “writer” lately. Are “blogger” and “writer” synonymous? I suppose so. I tell my students that if you write, you are a writer. However I think there is a difference between “writer” and “capital ‘W’ Writer”.

I definitely consider myself a writer (well, a Teacher-writer, if you want to be specific), but a Writer? I’m not sure.  I don’t think being published means you are automatically a Writer. I think there is more to it than that, but I haven’t figured out what. In the meantime, here are my answers to some interesting questions.



1. Do you share your work with your partner or spouse? Does it matter if it’s been published yet?

Yes, always. Cortney reads my blog regularly and I send him almost every draft of something I am going to submit for publication elsewhere. He is my biggest cheerleader in anything I do and really pushes me to go to the next level in teaching, learning, and writing. I smiled when I read that Stephen King also has his wife read everything he writes.

2. How much of your family and/or closest “friends in real life first” read your stuff…let alone give you feedback about it? 

Most of my readers are people I know “in real life”. My mom is probably second after Cortney in being my support. She doesn’t always agree with what I have written, but she proudly shares it with everyone and encourages me to keep writing.

My friends and other family members read it from time to time–when they see me post on Facebook and the topic interests them. Many members of my church have become readers, as well as some of my colleagues. Our church library even has one of the books I was published in on its shelves.

I’ve always been deeply honored when people I know tell me they read my writing and enjoy it. It’s also very humbling when former students, people I went to high school with, or past co-workers either approach me “in real life” or reach out via email or Facebook to tell me they enjoy what I write.  That keeps me going.

3. What do you do with the pieces that continually get rejected–post on your blog? Trash? When do you know it’s time to let it go?

The pieces that I have had rejected are either posted to my blog or kept for something else. I never know what I could revise and use again.

Rejection has taught me about who I am as a writer though, and what sorts of publications are more important to me than others. I find that I don’t fit many of the places that other bloggers find success submitting to. I don’t fit the mold that many places like the Huffington Post, Mamalode, etc are looking for.

While I do write about motherhood, most of those essays get rejected, and I’ve become Ok with that. I don’t naturally write beautiful, flowy pieces about being a mom. When I do, it’s usually something that just happens by chance.

The writing I get most recognition for are my opinion pieces and my posts on education. In fact, I’ve been published twice now in academic journals, and that is probably what I am most proud of.

4. Are there pieces you write for one very specific place that, once rejected, you just let go of, or do you rework into something else?

I don’t think I have ever just “let go” of a piece. If it didn’t start as something here on my blog, I will publish it here in some embodiment of it’s original whether I have to make it more “blog friendly” if it was academic, or revise it down to fit the attention span of blog readers.

5. What is your main source of reading-based inspiration (especially you essayists)? Blogs? Magazines? Journals? Anthologies? Book of essays by one writer?

I read a ton. I take very seriously Stephen King’s idea that if you don’t have time to read, you don’t have time to write.  I like to read books on the craft of writing, but I also just like to spend time with good writing–a good book that I can fall into for awhile. I get inspired by good writing.

I also try to read books on teaching pedagogy so I can stay abreast of best practice teaching. This leads me to try new things in my classroom and to write about it here (like I did with Reader’s Workshop and not assigning homework). I also read academic journals which both inspire me as a teacher and writer, but also give me ideas of what I can write about.

I like to read blogs as well. Lately I have been reading lots of political blogs and opinion blogs (but not the comment sections!)

6. What tends to spark ideas more for you: what you see/hear in daily life or what you read?

I think it’s equal parts experience and reading especially my teaching/writing posts and essays.  It’s hard to write about something you don’t experience, but reading really motivates me to write.

7. Who have you read in the past year or two that you feel is completely brilliant but so under-appreciated?

I think young adult literature is often under-appreciated. I know I never thought of it as “literature” until I started reading a TON of it over the past year in preparation for implementing a Reader’s Workshop in my classroom.  When I was the age my students are now, what I had available to me with teen protagonists was hardly good writing. Now I find myself spellbound by authors like Rainbow Rowell, Andrew Smith, and John Green.  I don’t think you have to have teenagers or teach them to fall in love with these books.

8. Without listing anything written by Dani Shapiro, Anne Lamott, Lee Gutkind, or Natalie Goldberg, what craft books are “must haves”?

I think it depends on the kind of writing you love to do. I appreciate Stephen King’s memoir, On Writing, but I also read a lot of “shop lit” (books about teaching writing) by Kelly Gallagher, Kylene Beers, Katie Wood Ray, Penny Kittle, and many others.

I also think sometimes reading authors that inspire your writing is sort of like reading a “craft book”. For instance I am largely influenced by Hemingway’s writing style of using very few words to convey very large ideas, but other than his posthumously published A Moveable Feast –which is more memoir than writing direction–there is not much writing advice he gives. I think many Writers don’t claim to know what will work for everyone; they only know what will work for themselves.

While I enjoy a good “craft” book, I don’t lean on them for a direct “Here is How to be a Capital “W” Writer” so much as I glean suggestions and ideas from them.

9. Have you ever regretted having something published? Was it because of the content or the actual writing style/syntax? 

Nope. No regrets. There have been a piece or two that I didn’t think was my best writing, but I don’t regret that it’s out there.  There are also pieces that I put out there that people read into in a way I didn’t expect, but again, I am not regretful or upset that I pushed “publish” or “send” on those pieces because they started conversations.

I’d love it if you answered a few of these. I’d also love it if you shared what YOU wonder about other writers too.

About Katie

Just a small town girl...wait no. That is a Journey song. Katie Sluiter is a small town girl, but she is far from living in a lonely world. She is a middle school English teacher, writer, mother, and wife. Life has thrown her a fair share of challenges, but her belief is that writing through them makes her stronger.


  1. I’d love to hear more about how you decide where to submit a given piece (either online or for an anthology or whatever). I have been a journalist for about 13 years but have always wanted to consider writing more about my personal experience and/or fiction.

    • Hi Ann! There are a few places that I watch for submissions to open. If I think I can fit their theme or prompt, I will write something. Sometimes I feel like it’s submit-able, sometimes not. I don’t write fiction, but I know there are LOTS of places online that have regular submissions to their sites or to print anthologies.

  2. I’m so glad you did this! I’m really proud of you for writing your opinion pieces about education, because as a hot button topic, people are VERY opinionated about this, and you’re never afraid to say where you stand, whether or not it’s a popular opinion. I also think that you write those well, because I always understand what you mean, and for someone who doesn’t live where you live, and have the same cultural and educational experience as you (or your other American readers) do, that is awesome.

    • Thanks, Alison! What a great compliment. My goal when I write about education here is to be accessible, not know-it-all-ish or to throw a bunch of academic jargon around. I want people–parents–to GET IT.

  3. Love these questions and I’m so glad that Kristen posted them. I agree entirely with what you (and Stephen King) say about reading as a major input to writing. I’m always taken aback when writers say they don’t have time to read. I need to find some of your opinion pieces!

    • I am too. I am also shocked when English teachers tell me they don’t have time to read. What?? That is what you TEACH!!! You MAKE time for that!

  4. I love how this meme keeps on getting more traction! I think it’s so great that your husband reads all your work and pushes you to reach the next level. How lovely and supportive. I’m still reminding my husband that I started a new blog a couple months ago 🙂 I also read about how Stephen King’s wife reads all his work and she was super supportive throughout his entire career, including the time when he was struggling, which I think is so wonderful.

    Glad to have found your blog!

    • Hi Dana! I’m glad you found your way here too! When I first started blogging (almost 8 years ago), I used to email my family (and husband) my post links. Ha! Now I figure they will either read or not.

  5. I like hearing that you may keep something to revise later. One of the things I took from when I saw David Sedaris what when someone asked him what he had done in Austin since he’d been here. “I worked,” he said. He is continually revising his essays, and we could even see him making little notes here and there as he was reading. Nothing is completely finished and free from revision.

    • I keep everything! And all things on my blog are always open to revision and re-use somewhere else…at least in my mind 🙂 Also I love David Sedaris. I almost listed him as a “craft book” that isn’t really a craft book, but inspires my writing (even though you wouldn’t know it because I am not funny..ha!)

  6. So much similarity here… 🙂 My husband reads everything, too. He (and my 8-yr-old) are my biggest cheerleaders. I was chuckling at your answer to #3. My writing doesn’t fit into “the mold”, either. But I’m truly okay with that. “I don’t write beautiful, flowy pieces…” <– Exactly. I write with my voice and that works for me. Another vote for YA lit. Yes! 🙂 I love your answer to #9. I need to adopt that attitude. Thanks and happy to have found your blog!

    • I always wonder if I should ignore typos and mistakes in my comments or point them out and laugh. You’re probably cringing so I’ll just say that I’m laughing.

  7. I love having this perspective on you as a writer. I get inspired by other writers not just from what they write, but how they write as well.


  1. […] title as this post here. One might call this a sort of blog chain letter. You see Katie Sluiter of Sluiternation was the third post, that I am aware of, with the same title. Now, I am the […]